Tag Archives: Russia

Sins of Omission

It’s not really related to malware, but this is an interesting article that brings up a few issues that should be highligthed.


Firstly, the cheque images in question are used as a security feature, you can view them online to see when and where they were cashed, and they are attached to a specific transaction. Those who don’t have a US bank account might not be familiar with such a system – however, the fact that the cheque now exists online should be a red-flag for security, and you would expect it to be protected as part of the bank account (your cheques, after all, have your signature on them, along with your bank details and a sample of your handwriting). The key to the success of this breach was that the images were all stored in a single online database. This in itself is a huge vulnerability.

Secondly, just because something is not a regulatory requirement, doesn’t mean that it shouldn’t be done as a matter of course. Holding such a database, and knowing that it contains data that would be very useful in fraud, then it makes sense to use encryption to protect it - so in this case fact that they were not encrypted simply makes it worse. It’s like saying that we were only required to put locks on the doors, but the regulations didn’t state we needed to close the windows.

Many European banks are moving away from paper driven cheques, and that would of course reduce or eliminate this specific attack, but what doesn’t seem to be happening is any assumption by the banks of attack. For instance, my bank has implemented some rudimentary anti-phishing protections, but it still uses a very weak password based account entry, which any key-logger could get around (unless of course I’m using a secure browser like K7SecureWeb or SafeCentral), and that combined with  a screen-scraper could easily compromise the anti-phishing measures.

Probably, as things get more serious (in terms of fraud) for the banks, there will be much more concentration on securing things. For now, the sad fact is that the consumers are not driving this, because they don’t care – the losses are to the banks, because of consumer protection (at least in the EU and USA). The reason my bank (along with most other British and US banks) have such poor security is that at the moment, the customers aren’t demanding higher security. That, coupled with silly things like only implementing the letter, rather than the spirit of regulation, is not going to bode well for the online banking in the near future.

Meanwhile, the Anti-malware industry gets a harder and harder rap for not being able to clean up all the mess, while what really needs to happen is for everyone to take a bit more responsibility for their actions, and understand that there are real threats out there, that cannot just be addressed by anti-malware alone, nor indeed any purely technology based solution.

Andrew Lee CISSP
AVIEN CEO / CTO K7 Computing