Category Archives: AVIEN Book

(Intellectual) Property is Theft?*

First of all, congratulations to Andrew Lee on his new role as CEO of ESET LLC. It’s as well that my work for AVIEN is unpaid, as otherwise he’d be my boss twice over. 😉 Reading the press release here, it includes substantial references to AVIEN and the AVIEN book, to which many AVIEN members contributed, as did Andrew and myself.

That was a very worthwhile project, but one of the less attractive aspects was the readiness of a great many people to generate and distribute pirated copies: apparently the time and effort it took us all to generate that book doesn’t deserve any recompense. In fact, I had a pirated PDF copy sitting on my desktop before my author’s (hard) copies arrived…. That wasn’t the first of my books to be pirated, let alone the only one. But it seems that the pace has picked up in recent years.

So imagine my joy on reading in the Vancouver Sun that ION Audio are about to market a device that can scan a 200-page book in 15 minutes. (Thanks to Robert Slade, my co-author on Viruses Revealed, for bringing this gem to my attention.) Well, it’s basically just a more ergonomic type of scanner, and hopefully dedicated pirates will find that having to turn all those pages by hand will still have a negative effect on their sex lives.

I don’t think there’s much doubt, though, that for every individual who has a legitimate and possibly legal reason to scan one of their books into machine-readable form (i.e. for iPad, Kindle etc.), there will be many more who will see this as a way to profit from the labour of others without asking the question “why do I have the right to assume that authors should go through the pain of writing and publishing with no right to any sort of return?”

What is really infuriating, though, is that it doesn’t seem to have occurred to ION that it is marketing rather more than a legitimate tool for honest students and educationalists. Or maybe it doesn’t care, because it can’t be used to copy ION hardware.

* http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Property_is_theft

David Harley CITP FBCS CISSP
AVIEN COO